Homeowners vs. Landlord vs. Renters

These three policies protect three different people with three different stakes in the same building. Mixing them up leaves either the structure or the belongings unprotected.

At a glance

Homeowners vs. Landlord vs. Renters — At a glance
	Homeowners (HO-3) HO-3	Landlord (DP-3) DP-3	Renters (HO-4) HO-4
What it covers	The structure you own and live in, your personal belongings, liability, and additional living expenses if the home is uninhabitable.	A rental property's structure and the owner's liability as landlord, plus loss of rental income - but not the tenant's belongings.	The tenant's personal belongings and liability, plus living expenses - but not the building itself.
When it applies	You own and occupy the home as your primary residence.	You own a property you rent out to others rather than live in.	You rent your home and want to protect what you brought into it.
Typical cost	Higher - it insures both the structure and its contents.	Moderate - covers the structure but not tenant contents; income coverage can add to it.	Low - often one of the least expensive policies, since no structure is insured.
Key limits or exclusions	Does not cover a home used mainly as a rental.	Does not cover the tenant's personal property or the tenant's liability.	Does not cover the building's structure or the landlord's liability.
Best suited for	Owner-occupants of a house.	Owners renting out a single-family home, condo, or small property.	Anyone renting an apartment, house, or room.

Who owns what, and who lives there

The right policy follows two facts: who owns the structure and who lives in it. Homeowners (HO-3) assumes you own and occupy the home, so it covers both the building and your belongings. Landlord (DP-3) assumes you own a property but someone else lives there, so it covers the structure and your risk as an owner - not the tenant's things.

Renters (HO-4) covers the opposite side: you don't own the building, so it insures your belongings and liability while the landlord insures the structure. Together, a landlord and renters policy cover one rented home from both angles.

How the pieces fit together

In a rental, two policies coexist. The landlord's DP-3 handles the walls, roof, and their liability; the tenant's HO-4 handles the couch, laptop, and the tenant's liability. Neither reaches into the other's territory, which is why a renter's belongings are unprotected if they skip an HO-4.

Where to find it in your policy

Your Declarations page policy type

Look for the form number - HO-3, DP-3, or HO-4 - which signals which of the three you actually hold.

The occupancy and Coverage A line

On homeowners and landlord policies, Coverage A - Dwelling shows a structure limit; a renters policy has no Coverage A because you don't insure the building.

Loss of use or fair rental value

Check whether the policy lists Additional Living Expense (owner-occupants and tenants) or Fair Rental Value (landlords), which confirms the intended occupancy.

What it looks like on a real claim

Example 1 — A kitchen fire in a rented house

A fire causes $60,000 of structural damage and destroys the tenant's $15,000 of furniture and electronics.

Homeowners (HO-3)

Would pay the $60,000 structure loss - but only if the owner lives there; it does not apply to a rented-out home.

Landlord (DP-3)

Pays the $60,000 structure damage and lost rent while repairs happen, but nothing for the tenant's furniture.

Renters (HO-4)

Pays the tenant's $15,000 in belongings and living costs, but nothing toward the building.

Example 2 — A guest is injured

A visitor slips and is injured, resulting in a $20,000 liability claim.

Homeowners (HO-3)

Covers the owner-occupant's liability up to the policy limit.

Landlord (DP-3)

Covers the landlord's liability as property owner, not the tenant's.

Renters (HO-4)

Covers the tenant's personal liability up to the policy limit.

The bottom line

Match the policy to your role: own and live there means HO-3, own and rent out means DP-3, rent and live there means HO-4. In a rental, the landlord and tenant each need their own.

The most common mistake is a tenant assuming the landlord's policy covers their belongings - it never does - or an owner keeping an HO-3 after turning the home into a rental, which can leave a claim denied.

Back to Personal Insurance Hub